A massive discussion ensues what teachers claim to be a controversial and "hurting" letter.
Some teachers have already interrogated and expressed their discontent over Juanhe's forum article published on Wednesday, 5 October 2005 in The Straits Times, commenting on how he shows "no respect" to them as teachers. On the other hand, Juanhe reiterates the point that he is not questioning whether teachers should be respected on this note but rather, the rationale of cutting queues during recess with other famished students like us when they have other free periods to buy food. He says that he has no intention to hurt any teachers through the letter, but rather, students and teachers should learn to maintain their mutual respect.
So should freedom of expression be made a sacrificial lamb to enable the teachers to exert their authority over us or just a preservation of it and their pride? A mini discussion in class 3M after lessons shall show us perhaps whether freedom of expression should be allowed, even though no intention to hurt the teachers or questioning their authority, ala Juanhe's post. Somehow the discussion breaks down to whether we should give unconditional respect to teachers.
Bing Wen says that respect should not be something that everyone must ask to have it, but rather, it is one in which everyone should do it. We should not even bother about asking why the person deserves it. Juanhe agrees somehow but asks whether one should accord respect to a person who does not show he deserves it. Daryl Eng mentions that the person must gain the respect of others, and what Mr Paul Lim does has reduced him to a friend rather than a person of higher authority with his blog. I continue by saying that we garner respect when we are in a particular status or job, and that we must maintain it such that people will not lose respect in regard to our status. However, the sanctity of respect as a person must nonetheless be uphold. This means that, we can choose not to give respect to a teacher as he or she may not be teaching well, however, we must accord respect for the teacher as a human being. Such a right should be unconditionally reserved to everyone and we must behave such that we do not degrade him or her as a person, such as insulting him directly in front of the rest.
Well, I believe having the freedom of expression means that, you should not override a person's authority to the rights as a human being. That is the minimum one can do.
With common tests looming, it is no doube that everyone will be gearing up to do well in the tests to pull up the horrible grades from Semester 2.
Semester 2 is without its bad luck. Teachers not putting in the full effort to educate us make it challenging for us to learn. Self-study does not work when you do not meet their criteria. It is so paradoxical that teachers want us to grasp the skills but yet they are not equipping us with that. People fear that their grades will plummet, others fear that they may even fail their tests.
Hopefully we can conclude our Secondary 3 life with a pleasant end at least.
When I read at Juanhe's forum article regarding mutual respect for both teachers and students, I gasp; when I see Teo Calvin's picture in The New Paper and him clarifying that his "future MRT Map" isn't meant to fool others, I am flabbergasted; when I see BattleCells cards being featured by our boys of National Television, I am surprised.
Imagine having three people making news within a span of twelve hours - half a day.
1. Juanhe's Forum Letter to Forum Editor
(published in The Straits Times, Wednesday, October 5, 2005)
Title: Respect must be earned, no two ways about it
Infuriated over the recent spate of "flaming" of teachers by students, Juanhe argues in his letter that "students nowadays are able to substantiate why their teachers ought to be criticised", such as in the canteen in which teachers have a priority to contend with hungry school children during recess to get their meals. He mentions that despite teachers having a higher status than students, but that does not warranty them to "openly flout what he believes is a school rule in many schools". To balance his point, students are being "overly critical of what their teachers say" and will not hesitate to shoot them down for every minute fault. To conclude, students should treat teachers with the gratitude they deserve and teachers should "work on their image and not do anything that may harm it".
As a general note it is a balanced argument and also reflects truly on every other school other than ours, even prestigious ones face this phenomenon. There is also no evidence of defaming the teachers in any sense neither does it side with the students alone. Yet some exasperated teacher has admonished him for writing it and it is likely that more complaints from teachers will follow suit. I don't see a reason why teachers should be angry over such things, and also why Singaporeans just cannot accept a single slight of comment like this. Singapore has already turned forty and so must the people grow up too. We should change our mindset and mentality to suit into the ever changing cosmopolitan and vibrant city Singapore has. Many Singaporeans still have this hierarchy-mindset in which we must respect those of higher authority regardless of their actions, knowing that it is for our own good, a la Confucius. Firstly, I do not believe highly that Confucius' thinkings and philosophy will serve well in a modern society. In imperial times his thinkings and the mindset of the populace at that time will have corroborated well enough to be passed down. Now, with emphasis of concepts such as democracy and equality for all, Confucius' ideas will slowly be replaced by new and more updated ideas. We should strike a balance of showing dignity to one another and also being able to accept each other's opinions. I do not want people to complain of the slightest remark others make regardless of their status, it shows how immature we are as a society - not being able to accept criticisms. Our mindset must also progress with the times.
2. Teo Calvin's Clarification of a Circulated Map of Future MRT and LRT lines
(published in The New Paper, Wednesday, October 5, 2005)
Title: I wasn't out to fool people
To clear the air of the mysterious circulating MRT map over the Internet and the "prankster" who has done it (The New Paper, September 23, 2005), Teo Calvin decides to call up reporter Kor Kian Beng on the issue. Speaking that it is unintentional of him to spread the map, Calvin mentions that it is meant to be a map to showcase the future lines and sations, and contributed it to Wikipedia. He feels that "there wasn't any around that showed the possible future lines and stations".
A quote on the clarification of the origin of the circulated map over email:But I think someone must have downloaded it from the website and then circulated it to others through e-mail.
Putting in immense amount of effort consulting a street directory to gauge distances between future stations, Calvin spent seven hours over a week to create the highly-authentic map. The New Paper, which interviews his father, says that he has put in a lot of effort and somehow agrees that it is a talent in which he and his elder brother possess. The Land Transport Authority is happy to note that he can pursue a career in land transport in the future though disapproving his work given some misleading points and copyright laws.
Nonetheless I find it good that Calvin has managed to clear the doubt surrounding the map depicting future lines and stations. Perhaps a note of precaution will be, not to publish it in the Internet to avoid such unnecessary trouble.
3. Showcasing BattleCards game on National Television
This is not of great issue but the creators, or rather, the innovators of the original BattleCards game from our school have been featured on the 6.30 news, revealing how these cards can definitely benefit teachers on incorporating innovative ways to educate students. By playing with these cards the innovators hope to market it to all educators. As far as I know the cards deal with biology, where one will require lots of memory to recall all the different specific terms being dealt in the discipline.
Having the hall intact and still under usage by the school populace but the canteen closed is probably one thing that will cause one to have stomach churns. Being forced to have meals at the Shaw Foundation Ceremonial Hall is probably what makes everyone lament, given the change in caterer and an another low in food quality.
Probably the decision to close down the canteen has been hasty. Firstly, long queues snake their way along the temporary stalls set up along the corridor even before the recess bell rings. So, many people are left to wait for long periods of time trying to order their food. To exacerbate the long queue situation the temporary stall holders, mostly supplied 'kindly' by Continental Delights Catering, who are unable to cope with the influx of students. They take so long to serve your food, and take so long just to give you your change. Even worse, somehow change runs out and these stall holders end up having to owe the customers. There are no familiar faces, except for the auntie from Cafe Delights working for the snacks store.
The food is roughly about 15 - 20% more expensive than that at our canteen. I believe they are overcharging people on canned drinks given that they tag it at 80 cents while the prices obviously and apparently indicate that they are 70 cents. The food looks pretty disgusting. Chicken chop really looks like the chicken is being chopped and served immediately. Mee rebus looks like cold dua mee with Japanese-curry like gravy laden onto it. Every food that is served looks cold and unappetising. Not even vegetables or fruits are served to complement our diet, despite the school's supposedly policy to encourage vendors to sell healthy food.
To contrast the standard of the food provided by the new stalls, we go over to RJC to have lunch. I think some will be grateful that RJC is around, for the food is much better. But one thing we don't understand is why the RJC people are coming over to our side to eat. Perhaps they are sick of the food there too.
There are two significant visits during the week, one to the Police Heritage Centre, the other to Parliament House.
1. Visit to Police Heritage Centre
A visit to the Police Heritage Centre is conducted on Wednesday, 28 September 2005. It is located on the lower floors of the Police Headquarters in the New Phoenix Park complex, where the twin towers bedecked the Novena area. The other tower is occupied by the Ministry of Home Affairs.
With heightened security, everyone is bag-checked and scanned for any suspicious objects or arms. Also, we need to exchange our individualised bus pass or identity cards for a visitor pass at the security post.
The Police Heritage Centre, should I say, should be appropriately called the Police Heritage Walkway. Firstly, it occupies a small fraction of the floor area, hence we should not call it a centre, and also, it literally is a walkway highlighting the achievements to the chronological developments in the Police force.
The features and presentation of the history of Police force, almost as old modern Singapore is, has striking resemblance to the all-so-glitzy Royal Selangor Visitor Centre or a trip down the History Museum. The first stop is already so modern and spectacular, highlighting the collection by the first two local Commissioner of Police and those who "died" during their course of duty. Well only a fraction of those in the Police force were killed during a confrontation or stand-off or an assault, the rest lost their lives in some form of traffic collisions, hence, were conferred to some form of post mortem honour on this glass adorned board. However, even few of them are accorded decorations and medals.
There are several interactive games and activities in which one can learn about the works and tasks of the Singapore Police Force. They include a game aiming to diffuse a bomb, in three difficulty levels, a wall featuring the milestones of the Police Force in brief among others. There is even a walkway through the history of the Police, noting the significant events and implementations to tie in with the situation. It really looks as though you are in a science centre or Singapore Discovery Centre. Perhaps the budget for the Ministry of Home Affairs is too much, sponsoring the maintenance and usage of public funds on such stuff instead of preventing terrorism and other security threats. :S
2. Visit to Parliament House
The visit to Parliament House serves as part of the Social Studies curriculm and it is conducted on Friday, 30 September 2005, in the afternoon. It is located behind the old Parliament House and was declared open on September 1999.
It is not easy to take a peek into the Parliament House. Firstly, you need to book a group visit with the in-charge, and secondly, security is as tight as the Police Heritage Centre if not more. There are some models depicting the decorum of the Speaker of Parliament, His chair and the procedures of Parliament. Portraits of the all the Speakers of Parliament are displayed with a short writeup on each of them. Also, pictures showing all ten Parliament since Singapore's self-governance are displayed along the walk of fame.
Inside the Parliament Chamber are two separate levels, the lower level where Parliament sits, the upper level for strangers and dipolmats, also known as the Stranger's Chamber. A certain form of etiquette must be observed or else he can be thrown out of the Chamber. It is pretty high-tech in there, one, in the Stranger's Chamber, you have a headset connecting to the various channels in different languages, meant as a form of translation to whatever is being said in Parliament for those who cannot understand English. There is an automatic voting system for all Members of Parliament to speed up decision making and plasma screeens will show the results. Previously in the old Parliament House the Stranger's Chamber isn't present, but the grandeur and architecture there is very much well-liked.
It is indeed a golden opportunity being able to visit these two places given that it is not easy to go there due to security reasons.