Colours

Leviathan's Blog, Version 13

A massive discussion ensues what teachers claim to be a controversial and "hurting" letter.

Some teachers have already interrogated and expressed their discontent over Juanhe's forum article published on Wednesday, 5 October 2005 in The Straits Times, commenting on how he shows "no respect" to them as teachers. On the other hand, Juanhe reiterates the point that he is not questioning whether teachers should be respected on this note but rather, the rationale of cutting queues during recess with other famished students like us when they have other free periods to buy food. He says that he has no intention to hurt any teachers through the letter, but rather, students and teachers should learn to maintain their mutual respect.

So should freedom of expression be made a sacrificial lamb to enable the teachers to exert their authority over us or just a preservation of it and their pride? A mini discussion in class 3M after lessons shall show us perhaps whether freedom of expression should be allowed, even though no intention to hurt the teachers or questioning their authority, ala Juanhe's post. Somehow the discussion breaks down to whether we should give unconditional respect to teachers.

Bing Wen says that respect should not be something that everyone must ask to have it, but rather, it is one in which everyone should do it. We should not even bother about asking why the person deserves it. Juanhe agrees somehow but asks whether one should accord respect to a person who does not show he deserves it. Daryl Eng mentions that the person must gain the respect of others, and what Mr Paul Lim does has reduced him to a friend rather than a person of higher authority with his blog. I continue by saying that we garner respect when we are in a particular status or job, and that we must maintain it such that people will not lose respect in regard to our status. However, the sanctity of respect as a person must nonetheless be uphold. This means that, we can choose not to give respect to a teacher as he or she may not be teaching well, however, we must accord respect for the teacher as a human being. Such a right should be unconditionally reserved to everyone and we must behave such that we do not degrade him or her as a person, such as insulting him directly in front of the rest.

Well, I believe having the freedom of expression means that, you should not override a person's authority to the rights as a human being. That is the minimum one can do.

0 Response for the "The Sanctity of Freedom of Expression versus Authority"

    Interaction

    Friends