The climate talks in Copenhagen are set to open this Monday with a hope to renew a contract to reduce greenhouse gases that are believed to be at the heart of widespread climate change globally. With a slew of alarmist news of melting ice caps, vanishing snow peaks in Mount Kilimanjaro and the Himalayas, and extreme weather at hand, experts warn that it will be ‘too late’ to reverse the change if world leaders do not agree with a new pact that is set to replace the Kyoto Protocol, due to expire in 2012.
Lofty plans to implement joint funds to initiate carbon-reducing technologies to less-developed countries and an active plan to develop alternative energy sources on a large-scale basis have been placed on the table when leaders arrive in the Danish capital this week. So are talks on the wider implementation of the cap-and-trade schemes that are at the cornerstone of the Kyoto Protocol. With so much at stake, many leaders, to appease environmentalists and those affected by climate change, feel obliged or responsible to introduce or renew current legislation to demonstrate that the effects of climate change have been curbed. But frankly, these big ideas and plans are going to fall apart if consumerism and population growth are left unchecked.
Simple economics tell us that nothing will be done if the average utility earned is zero or below, for the fact that marginal cost rises over zero for producing a good. It only makes economic sense if countries stand to benefit from initiating carbon-reducing technologies in the less-developed nations. Wholesale importing of technologies to reduce emissions from burning of ‘dirty’ fuel into developing nations will pose many problems, including the high cost of maintaining and training a highly-educated labour to sustain it. And no company will possess such an immense amount of altruism to distribute and share such expertise so freely so that the problem can be mitigated as soon as possible without incurring huge costs and lack of reciprocation from developing nations. Adapting new technology to provide a constant supply of energy is a costly measure that many governments in developing nations are unable to budget, and most of the time plundering among government officials will almost certainly derail any efforts in environmental conservation.
The funding is but a very small effort by developed countries to ascertain their commitment in this important summit in Copenhagen; what remains to be seen is how much they will go in ensuring that developing countries are able to curb greenhouse emissions without compromising their growing economies. A seemingly insurmountable, mammoth task of reducing emissions need not arise from cookie-cutter (and of course expensive) solutions, instead adapting and innovating cheap solutions can go a long way in achieving a larger cause. With companies coming up with cheap pills to sanitise river water into drinking water, or even to immunise against common tropical diseases in Africa, illustrate that solutions to climate change require more thoughtful thinking that will allow the plan to function in an almost idiot-proof manner – that even the least-educated of people can work towards the goal without forfeiting their chance at sustaining their livelihoods. Comprehending local situations is an imperative and a great asset to leaders to come up with more appropriate initiatives if there is any chance of alleviating a growing and pressing environmental issue.
While many countries and environmentalists have pushed for cap-and-trade schemes to penalise developed countries for failing to comply with emission limits and thus having to buy up credits from those who emit much less emissions than the standard, talks on its detriments have not been discussed much actually. Scientist James Hansen, who heads NASA Goddard Institute for Space Studies in New York, revealed a possibility in his interview with The Guardian of developed nations wanting to continue “business as usual” would buy credits from developing nations, who in turn will stand to gain money. In turn, his analysis, which he described the policy as “fundamentally wrong”, reveals that nothing will actually be done since developed countries continue to pollute and add to the greenhouse gases in the atmosphere while developing countries make money and continue to pollute as well since new technologies aimed at cutting emissions will not be adopted. And the cycle of money laundering, corruption and misappropriating of funds will ensue in these developing countries. So as much as many will like to push for the cap-and-trade schemes for it does not affect the free-market mechanism, self-interest and self-indulgence that are so inextricably inherent in humans will likely see any efforts towards lower emissions be nullified.
Great plans do not necessarily translate to the best plans. In fact, there are many problems that have to be ironed out and yet time and time again, after repeated alarmist news from environmentalists on the degradation of the world’s climate and environment, leaders think that large-scale policies will likely succeed when the effects are often short-term and problematic. Furthermore the consequences of increasing consumerism and population growth are also playing a big role in causing climate change, since more resources (and energy) are required to satiate the burgeoning needs (and wants) of a booming population. The solution is not a one-size-fits-all, and it will surely require much thought, understanding of the various circumstances that vary so greatly from place to place, and of course a clamp on increasing consumerism and self-interest for any plans to combat climate change to work at the very least.
0 Response for the "Development with Care for Environment: It’s Not That Simple"
Post a Comment