Colours

Leviathan's Blog, Version 13

Worldwide flak was drawn for its unethical premise: three contestants vying for a supposed terminally ill patient's kidney, and then, the real intention is revealed, to the surprise and relief of many who proclaim it a wonderful tactic to appeal for kidney donations. The Dutch reality TV show The Big Donor Show, created by Endemol who likewise began the Big Brother and Deal or No Deal franchises, attracted much international attention and criticism initially for disparaging life-and-death matters towards providing entertainment. The true identity of 'Lisa', who was introduced as having six months to live and deciding to donate a kidney for a friend of hers died of kidney failure, turns out to be an actress.

Three true-life patients awaiting a kidney for a new lease of life, Esther-Claire, Vincent and Charlotte, are part of the 'conspiracy' to appeal to the Dutch audience for organ donation. Journalists and reporters flock to the television studio where the show is held, only to find their stabbings of the show unfounded, and Culture Minister Ronald Plasterk praises it as 'a fabulous stunt'. While neither will receive a new kidney after the show, they sincerely hope that their beck will motivate the people to sign up to be donors.

It seems like an insipid cookie cutter, insipid reality TV formula being employed for a life-and-death situation to boost ratings, and an encroachment into the sensitivities of conservatives and ethics, but when the cat is finally let out the bag, everything seems to be seen in a different light. Probably no one will have thought of using the overly-publicised reality TV recipe to concoct a powerful driving message for a charitable cause. And despite drawing initial opprobrium, it is heartening to note that there has been no malicious intent in the broadcast of this show. And for as long as a show drives home the message to be generous without causing any harm, any form of such promotion should be allowed and encouraged, for it is hard to draw attention of ordinary folks of the plight of these patients.

While emotional pleas have been exploited for a truly good cause, it is hoped that they will continue to be used for only a truly good cause, unlike the extravagant and lavish charity shows run by National Kidney Foundation before the scandals erupted. Actors performing 'high-risk' stunts just to raise over $10 million in funds, but yet much of it lands in the pocket of the former executive committee, which is now awaiting verdict for criminal charges.

Ethos is a very powerful method of persuading someone for a cause. Like technology, it depends on how it is being used, for good or for bad. While the international media has misgivings about such a show initially, the motive in which the producers have has been attained, and to the relief and praise of using an ingenious way to promote a charitable cause.

0 Response for the "Emotional Pleas"

    Interaction

    Friends