It was novel, exhilarating, the golden opportunity to chase one dreams in singing their hearts out and gather the attention of all. August 9, 2004 saw the broadcast of the first Singapore Idol series. Thousands of enthused people beat the torrential rains and thunder at Suntec Convention Centre to wait for their turn to sign up for the inaugural competition.
Two years later, into the second series, the viewership numbers have fallen. The audience has been exposed to a plethora of spinoffs in the other three national languages, other competitions with similar format based on acting skills, and now, dancing and being a comedian. Have the viewers at home endured enough from an excessive bombardment of such shows?
While Singapore Idol's concept is borrowed heavily from the successful franchise of American Idol, the reason why it has not been as successful within the country over time is probably due to lack of talents and tactful wit from the judges. While the international media recognises Simon Cowell, the acid-tongued judge in American Idol, to be one of the more memorable characters in reality television, the Singapore spinoff just falls through based on the image presented by the judges and the attempted mimicking of Simon. Dick Lee was criticised for being utterly rude to one contestant in the first series, by promptly telling off a flabbergasted contestant to get out. Now Jacintha has been put off by some for making insignificant and useless comments to contestants.
It was once said that Singapore Idol will not be held annually as Singapore has a small talent pool and identifying good talents in singing is harder. But yet, in the span of two years, we see three Chinese spinoffs, a Malay spinoff and even a Tamil spinoff. So many replicas of the same old concept and voting system certainly does not justify this comment.
Some viewers are also exasperated by how some better contestants are promptly eliminated through the telepoll voting system. And the problem with the voting system, and also democracy, surfaces. Tyranny of the majority is a weakness of the voting system. One can work his or her way into the finals by generating a large fanbase or gathering support from family members. Ways to get through include creating one's unique fashion sense, be it hip or dysfunctional or morbid, or having some form of disabilities or handicapp. Perhaps Project Superstar is one such example.
Furthermore such a voting system, the organisers say, will be fairer as more people are able to judge the contestants' abilities, though it has become apparent it has served as a function to determine the number of people who sympathise or support a person's fashion statement. Anyway the organisers have no intention to scrap it as the voting system is a lucrative system. Costing 60 cents per call, and noting that 1.1 million votes were received for the finals for Idol, we can imagine the revenue generated from this simple cause.
To appease calls that such systems are unfair, some competitions have taken the judges' scores into account. But given that this takes a small percentage in the overall result, the fate of the contestants still lie in the lopsided voting process.
Leaving contestants of substandard qualities on stage due to the voting system has led to dwindling viewership generally. Other than the contestants' admirers and ardent fans, no sane person will put himself or herself to an hour of psychological torture listening to these contestants' horrible renditions. And hearing insignificant comments by the judges and lack of personality of the hosts contribute to poor character of these shows.
Perhaps viewers should be spared from this onslaught of blatant rip-offs of reality television and be pampered with proper, good quality television shows. Such spinoffs have become stale and will not appeal to anyone in the long run. Television shows should be a good mix of drama, education and variety to nourish the soul and mind. We should realise that such shows are not the way to go in the future.
0 Response for the "All But a Farce"
Post a Comment