Colours

Leviathan's Blog, Version 13

As part of the finals of the Saint Margaret’s Secondary School Humanities Challenge, the team would have to prepare a five-minute long presentation on the discussion of the issue on whether the rise of China and India would be an opportunity or a threat.

Deviating from the clichéd, standard textbook answer of yes, the team comprising Alan Koh, Ronald Chan, Li Qian and me has taken the issue to another dimension, arguing its threat from a totally fresh perspective – political. Arguing over the possibility of a oil-hungry China invading Siberia in the hope of exploiting its treasure trove of natural resources and an over-heated economy and yearn to develop an Pan-Asian Security and Economic Pact to expand its powers and markets, the team focuses on a tough decision needed to be made by the Singapore Cabinet on whether to support China on its cause or not. Later, the team argues on the diplomatic stand India has to adopt given its militarily-formidable neighbours and the need for it to abstain from being coerced into forming alliances and being members of a pact.

Spending the two days before the competition day, the team brainstorms many possible scenarios that would occur as of 2051, such as territorial expansion of China to absorb Taiwan, North and South Korea, Vietnam, Laos, Myanmar and Mongolia under its rule and the impending crisis that other major superpowers such as the United States and European Union would predict to occur. By 2051, oil in the Middle East would run out and interest would shift to the untouched treasures of Siberia, where the major superpowers would fight head to toe to gain control of a lucrative business opportunity and the concomitant power in controlling world affairs.

In addition to a skit, a PowerPoint presentation slide is used to enable the audience to easily follow the proceedings, featuring a mock front page article of The Straits Times on China invading the eastern Russian city of Vladivostok and a Mercator projection of the countries and bloc positions.

The Day Itself

The five top schools, including Hwa Chong Institution, Anglican High School, Saint Joseph Institution and Zhonghua Secondary School, battle it out for the first position through three rounds, first round the rapid fire round, second round involving students to take a stand and the last round, the Take a Stand round, in which we have prepared in into the night.

The first round consists of two sections. First section allows all teams to answer fifteen questions on current affairs and general knowledge, which proves to be too easy for everyone. Second section is the buzzer round, in which Anglican High, Hwa Chong and our school seem to encounter some technical problem rather than lack of nimble fingers in buzzing the questions. The questions prove to be too easy and it all reduces to a battle of quick fingers and whether the buzzer and the equipment are to the team’s advantage. So Saint Joseph Institution manages to sweep most of the questions and we are trailing them by ten points, which Alan Koh feels depressed.

In the second round, teams are given a box containing four items, in which members have to link them up using concepts in social studies to form a complete picture or systematic mind map of ideas. Using the items, one team member would have to convey the relations between the objects and demonstrate his clarity and insight. We see a haughty Saint Joseph Institution faltering for this section as they blabber their way in circles on the Westernisation of Asia, repeating the point on McDonalds sprouting everywhere in Asia and the world etc. Similarly the other schools do not perform as well and we put up a sterling performance by drawing all items to the concept of globalisation, which eventually win the hearts of the three distinguished judges.

As for the last round the same problems faced by the other four teams resurface. Most of the teams, as we predicted, focus mainly on the economic aspect and of the present age, hence missing the point on "the future". As usual some teams repeat the mistake of beating about the bushes and keep re-emphasising the same points over and over again, and these teams all argue based on the economic aspect, and not on the political aspect which is equally pertinent.

Finally our sterling performance for the last two rounds is duly rewarded by attaining the challenge shield once again and beating all other schools with a convincing score-line of 95 to 69 (Saint Joseph), 68 (Zhonghua), 65 (Hwa Chong) and 58 (Anglican High). It is indeed rewarding to note that what matters most is not what one knows, but rather what one is able to reflect and ponder on the world we know today.

0 Response for the "Slow and Steady Wins the Race"

    Interaction

    Friends