As an eleventh church was vandalised in the ongoing “Allah” court ruling controversy, the incumbent Barisan Nasional government led by UMNO seemed to be unfazed by the threat posed to pluralism and religious freedom. In Malaysia whereby recent developments have placed the country on the track towards radical Islam, the recent development on the flip-flops given on the use of the sacred word by non-Muslims in their religious texts and sermons has added to the increasing extremist thinking by UMNO leaders and paranoia that grapples the way religion and politics are handled.
Radicalisation of politics grew when PAS reinstated sharia law in its controlled states of Terengganu and Kelantan, and saw Barisan Nasional’s version of Islamic governance watered down. When United States invaded Afghanistan and Iraq post 9/11, PAS actively condemned the non-Muslim attacks on Muslims and encouraged members to fight alongside the Taliban. However, the twist of fate changed as resentment and anger grew over Barisan Nasional’s failure to promote greater economic growth and its faltering racial policies after the massive crackdown on HINDRAF demonstrators in November 2006. With elections looming in 2008 and its coalition in the PKR, PAS was somewhat forced to tone down on its radical Islamist ideologies to woo non-Muslims to support the PKR in dismantling and loosening the 50-year grip of power by the BN. Indeed, a greater percentage of Malays, besides the Chinese and Indians, voted for the PKR in the elections and denied a two-third majority in the Parliament.
As PAS, in its multi-racial coalition, gradually became more inclusive and accepting of other religions, BN grew more extremist in its desperate attempt to regain the Malays’ support, its major support base. Where cases such as Chinese buried in Muslim rites, wrongful conversion to Islam and now the use of the word "Allah” whereby it posed no problems beforehand, illustrated an increasing attempt to emotionally rob Malays to align themselves to the BN for its efforts in instilling Islamic principles, while alienating the other races further. Despite BN’s call for calm, the fact that so many churches were torched or damaged after a period of two weeks demonstrated the sheer lack of will by the government to mobilise the police to clamp down on these acts. Furthermore, the government-linked papers like Utusan continued to stoke racial and religious tensions by explaining that the ruling would embolden other religions to use “Allah” at the expense of denigrating the sanctity of the word in Islamic texts and Islam. Besides, certain factions within UMNO, the ruling partner in BN, have pointed out how the handling of the crisis would compromise on BN’s ability to lead the country in the coming years, hinting at growing extremism within the party. A disturbing development to note, that the very tenets of BN to include all races (despite its policies slanting towards benefitting the Malays under bumiputra) are precisely being dismantled because UMNO is struggling to maintain strong support from the Malays, while neglecting its commitments to the other races. And on the converse, PAS is moving towards a more moderate stance under the PKR, calling for a inter-faith dialogue on the controversy in the hope to garner support from moderate Muslims as well as non-Muslims.
With two opposing multi-racial coalitions in Malaysia heading for different directions in racial and religious politics, the problem of racial politics remains. As long as a policy favouring Malays (and Muslims) stands, discrimination and religious intolerance will prevail – multi-party coalitions will find it sticky appealing to a majority Malay population while appeasing the needs of their respective communities. But moving towards an extremist take on religious affairs will definitely head nowhere in promoting mutual tolerance and understanding.