Singapore Science and Engineering Fair 2008 plays host to over 300 projects 15 different categories, the largest ever in its history. With projects ranging from physics and engineering to chemistry, biology and mathematics, the fair is a two-day event held on 5 and 6 March 2008 in an attempt to showcase the very 'best' in 'scientific' research. (I'll explain the inverted commas later).
On the 4th March, the various participants arrive at the Annexe to put up their colourful posters. Amid familiar faces and not-so-familiar ones, everyone somehow was helping each other to mount the posters onto the boards using the Velcro provided. Colours and the quality of the poster materials are indeed deceiving. Some interesting, immaculate, impeccable projects are adorned in relatively dull colours, but some beautiful posters however feature little or no significance. For mine, it is somewhere in between.
The next day, a day marred by the pattering of the rain (a harbinger of bad things to occur?), all teams undergo a very intensive and gruelling judging by a panel of three arbitrary judges. Indeed, these judges, supposedly professional with years of knowledge and expertise in their fields, would be assigned to each of the participating projects for the judging. While I wait impatiently next to my poster for some two hours, I can see some teams experiencing an overwhelming interrogation by some ruthless judges who would point at each part of the poster and find faults with their methodology and scientific thinking. Others are asked strange, irrelevant questions which are totally out of scope and hence a response cannot be produced satisfactorily. For the first time, I really wonder whether the judging is ever 'fair' for all, given the different treatment and type of questions posed by the judges. Perhaps it is really a lottery as you are never sure what sort of judges you will get.
My turn to present comes at 11.30am, with the first (Chinese) judge allowing me to present and clarifying some points. It is a decent judging so to speak, as he nods at certain points during my presentation. I shake his hands after my first judging. After a hiatus during lunch, I receive two more judges. The two judges are poles apart. On one hand, I have a judge who praises me for my 'ingenious' idea and says that my project is good, whilst the other, upon first impression, seems to despise my mentor (and his students and of course my project) and begins to pose weird questions that are contrary to what my mentor and the students told me beforehand. For the nuclear magnetic resonance spectra, he insists that one can integrate the hydride peak (in the upfield region) just like a proton peak to get the ratio of hydrogen atoms with different coupling. Apparently, this cannot be done due to different strengths in each one of the signals. Somehow, the third judge isn't convinced, and proceeds to ask more irrelevant questions on the specifics of organometallic reactions (gosh even the research papers don't publish such stuff!). At the end of the third judge's 'bashing', I know that I won't get anything for sure (despite the "All the best" comment from the third judge when I wrap up).
The public exhibition day is held on 6 March, with many students from NUS High School and a few others from other schools attending the exhibition. Given the 'fated' outcome the previous day, I have no mood to tend my booth and decide to go around visiting other booths to know more about the other projects. And at around 3pm the awards are given out to the winning projects. Interestingly, the number of Chemistry projects getting at least a Merit is remarkably low - a mere 4 out of over 35 projects, and a sign of differentials in judging standards. Of course engineering biology projects sweep a greater proportion of prizes. What one cannot fathom is how a mathematics project that is purely based on derivation (relationship between the circumradius and inradius I think) has won a Gold and a project on how to tackle the Indonesian haze bags a Silver (it is in the category of behavioural science, but little to do with the topic it seems). I am totally flabbergasted at the outright unfairness in this competition despite my third year here. And to my shattered hopes my project fails to garner any award, which I believe isn't due to a lack of effort throughout the project on my part but inconsistencies in judging.
Anyway as prestigious as the fair sounds, SSEF sure has some if not a lot of luck involved. Good or lax judges can bring a lousy project up many notches, while a good project can be shot down by really lousy judges who either have the wrong mindset in grading projects or do not even know what the heck is the topic. Hopefully future participants can take note of the luck factor involved - a constituent of a make or break in this fair.