In a news conference on Wednesday, Health Minister Khaw Boon Wan spoke about the former management of the National Kidney Foundation (NKF) in response to an independent KPMG report released on Monday on NKF's financial operations and accounts. Khaw revealed that the government will press for charges where there have been criminal breaches at the NKF, in the wake of a damning auditor's report on Singapore's largest charitable organisation.
The report revealed that former Chief Executive Officer T. T. Durai had increased his salary three times over the past ten years and his pay rise was backdated for up to eleven months. In addition, first-class air tickets costing up till ten of thousands were not utilised and some of them were only partially used. NKF's tangible results on patients and healthy reserves were misleading, and even fabricated, adding that the way Mr. Durai ran the NKF was flawed. Figures on the number of 'beneficiaries' include 210,000 adults and other school children who underwent the NKF's health screenings, expenditure on charity shows were reported to be over $1 million lesser, undeclared pay rise by the Board of Directors were among the pitfalls of bad corporate governance. As a result, only 10% of donations went to the beneficiaries. Indeed the extensive emphasis that NKF is a non-profit organisation and proclamation of good corporate governance was seen as a mere 'facade'.
Mr. Durai seemed phlegmatic when faced upon the constant onslaught of charges against his former governance over Singapore's largest charitable organisation. During the first revealations in July, Durai, sitting next to Khaw, was totally unfazed despite increasing acrimony from the public over the allegations. The KPMG report noted that Durai seemed adamant when the Board of Directors recommended a pay rise for him, however, he accepted a much higher pay rise when the Board of Directors agreed to it.
In Wednesday's press conference, Khaw continued that the government was misled into believing that nothing went wrong within the NKF's organisational structure, even patron Mrs. Goh Chok Tong. Furthermore, NKF was audited over the years but weaknesses went unnoticed, Khaw noted, perhaps the government had placed their trust on NKF over the past decade since its inauguration of its services to kidney patients in 1969, and hence did not suspect anything fishy over the management. Even KPMG audit of tax deductible review in 2004 did not uncover flaws, until a defamation case over Singapore Press Holdings' journalist revealed the flaws. Khaw remarked that the board and CEO Durai were "disappointing" and the government, the regulators and the public were duped by their misdeeds, and acknowledged that the government had failed to regulate the organisation properly and revealing it earlier, in addition, his earlier mistake in siding with the NKF.
Khaw said that the government will fix the problem of the integration of the many agencies, which resulted in lack of clarity in the regulatory structure, which became subjected to exploitation, within the next three months. This could have changes to the legislation.
The NKF was set up to subsidise the high costs of dialysis by kidney patients. Given a long history, many Singaporeans have placed their trust on it, with even the wife of former Prime Minister Goh Chok Tong endorsing it as a Patron, nobody will have dared to question the runnings of the organisation. It is highly regrettable that such an incident should be allowed to take place, and worse till, allowed it to drag for almost a decade. Apparently the Board of Governors, including auditors abetted in toto to misappropriate public funds to pamper themselves and fulfil their non-essential needs. It is plausible that the National Council of Social Service (NCSS) had not been doing their work properly, resulting into this long-drawn saga. Indeed the NKF has chosen to adopt a business-centric model in its corporate governance, with its lavish medium-rise headquarters at Kim Keat Road adorned with glass. From video excerpts on national television we see that the interiors are adorned with sofas and even a concierge, which one may think, resembles a hotel.
NKF shifted its strategic focus into the Children's Fund and Cancer Fund in the last few years, bombarding the seemingly variety-show-deficient national television with charity shows after charity shows for different causes. And as usual we see Taiwanese host Timothy Cao reinforcing donation hotlines consistently (by right they should start with 1800-xxx-xxxx) claiming to be an ambassador to the NKF until it is revealed in the evening dailies that he actually profitted from the shows. Extravagant prizes, cars, condominiums, cash, etc, were given away, making the show into a live gambling/lottery show. In the end, the donations landed up mostly into the pockets of the Board of Directors as revealed by the report.
We see that this highly controversial, long drawn saga involving NKF can be avoided totally. If NCSS had placed more focus into checking the NKF, this whole incident will not have taken place at all. Overall there must be a regulatory to check on all charities in Singapore, ensuring public funds are not misused. To have a clearer picture on this whole incident, checks should be made into MediaCorp in the production of the charity shows to check whether MediaCorp did profit from this incident. A few questions remain why the Health Ministry was totally deceived and oblivious to the workings of NKF leading up to the saga, and also of MediaCorp's role in this. For now it appears that this problem is highly exclusive to the former NKF's Board of Directors, and it is good that most of the problems have been dug out and the new management, led by Gerard Ee, ironing out the complexities and starting things afresh.
>> IN ADDITION: On Thursday's Straits Times, Jason Tan writes in to the Forum querying on the accounts of the Singapore Heart Foundation. From figures lifted from the website, he noted that administrative expenses for 2004 were a whooping $1.712 million, fund-raising costs added up to $766,900 and funds directly for beneficiaries were a mere $297,800. It is surprising that another charitable organisation's accounts are similar to that of NKF in terms of breakdown. It appears that if a saga revolving the Heart Foundation were to occur, it had better to be now so that better management of charities can take into effect as soon as possible.
As an add-on to Timothy Chow's post dated 18 December 2005, we shall review some of the wacky and somehow 'absurd' things around Singapore.
1. Changi Airport Budget Terminal
To capitalise on the tremendous growth and potential of budget travelling in Asia, Singapore has decided to go on early this year with the building of a low-cost budget terminal, comprising two adjacent buildings, for low-cost carriers at Changi Airport. Due for opening in March 2006, the new single-storey facility will boost a no-frills design, with no elaborate baggage handling system, escalators, aero-bridges and travellators, however, shops catering food and selling other apparels will be provided. The cost of airlines to use the terminal is $8 cheaper than that at the more lavish Terminals 1 and 2 with a sleek, contemporary flair and more facilities. So far, only Tiger Airways have decided to use the terminal while other airlines have not expressed interest.
Given that passengers still have to pay other taxes such as landing and parking facilities, the percentage discount by using the budget terminal will be minimal. Furthermore given that the terminal is not air-conditioned and only the basic amenities are available, the budget terminal may shun passengers from visiting there. No doubt other budget carriers have not chosen to utilise this additional, non-essential multi-million dollar facility which now caters to a sole national carrier. Somehow it is not sensible to build something which strips it to its bare necessities when passengers nowadays demand quality services on top of the basic. Perhaps the basis of budget travelling is to get from point A to point B at an economical (cheaper than economy class seats) rate rather than the no-frills idea. Wonder how Tiger Airways, a subsidary of Singapore Airlines, will fare once it shifts to the low-cost terminal.
2. Buangkok Station and Circle Line Stage 1
After a two-and-a-half-year delay, Hougang residents can finally cheer when Buangkok station will open its doors next month. It seems like bad foresight has plagued the transport arena these few years. First the eleventh-hour decision not to open the station together with the other 14 stations on the Northeast Line seems unreasonable and appalling. Now, SBS Transit decides to open it as residents shift into the new nearby flats to be ready then, though there are already residential apartments within the vicinity of the station. And this decision happens to coincide with talks of an impending General Elections. A carrot one may guess, like Potong Pasir station during the 2001 General elections, once mentioned to be close "until further development", which opened eventually.
Onto the delayed opening of Circle Line Stage 1 till 2010, which commenced construction in 2002, it is deemed insensible that the four stations, Dhoby Ghaut, Bras Basah, Esplanade and Promenade will remain closed till Stages 4 and 5 will be expected to open its doors then. As a result of the Nicoll Highway collapse, the station has to be shifted 100 metres to Republic Avenue to bypass the affected area now buried with wrangled steel bars and a mixture of 'soft' concrete and soil. While tracks for the Stage 1 have already being laid (if you see The Straits Times recently there is a picture depicting the tunnels) and equipment and electrical cables being installed, we shall expect the stations to lay still and gather dust for the next three years or so till the runup of its scheduled opening. And yes, the first Circle Line train, manufactured by Alstom, is expected to be delivered from France in 2006 to Kim Chuan depot. A good suggestion will be to construct the tunnel box first to re-link the twin tunnels to that at Stadium station, so that while constructions are undergoing at Nicoll Highway (or rather Republic Avenue), the four stations will be functional together with Stages 2 and 3, scheduled to open in 2008, than to let it rot.
Adventurer Khoo Swee Chiow has attempted yet another task aimed at breaking the world record. This time, he aims to break the world scuba diving record for immersing himself in a tank filled with mineral water for ten days. Critics and readers have chided him for using public funds for self-glorification purposes, wasting the Northeast Community Development Council (CDC) $150,000 to pursue his "trivial pursuit". Some have even commented that the Northeast CDC has sponsored him thrice over the year, even though it is clearly stated that one can be sponsored once based on the merits of the activity under the Dare to Dream fund.
Reader Robert Yeo mentions in his forum letter that the Northeast CDC "has been misguided into sponsoring Khoo's attempt at self-glorification". Indeed one will definitely wonder why so much money is being used to organise such an event which does not benefit any charitable organisation or the society. Khoo responds by saying that whatever challenge he takes has strings attached and that he must give motivational talks to residents under the care of the Northeast CDC as a form of reciprocal, and his feats are seen as motivation for his son.
Rather than allowing other to sponsor oneself for a task that is aimed at self glorification, since setting a new world record is involved, or as a form of motivation, there are other ways in which one can achieve the latter. To achieve the former, it will be wiser if the cause is to enable others, especially the less fortunate, to receive benefits from one's task. Dr. William Tan's 48-hour marathon at ITE East is one good illustration. It is true that what Khoo Swee Chiow has been doing over the years does not benefit Singapore in any way except for his fame.
This Sunday we will herald the arrival of the first major charity event after the President's Challenge and a Cancer Charity Show by the original Singapore Cancer Society on Channel 8 since the National Kidney Foundation (NKF) controversy.
The Singapore Heart Foundation's Affairs of the Hearts show will employ similar fund-raising tactics as what NKF charity shows have been doing for the past few years. Extraordinary feats which place Singapore's celebrities in place in great deal of pain in the name of goodwill, and hoping that Singaporeans will be touched by that. In addition, overly-featured singers Kelly Poon and Tan Weilian will be singing to the audience's content and extravagant prizes are to be given out "as a reciprocal for those who donate generously" (a common catchline used during NKF charity shows). Lastly, the show will never forget to showcase true lives stories to show that there are people who have to put up with horrible medical conditions.
Whether the continued usage of a highly-proven tactic to generate enough funds for the Heart Foundation will once again be successful will depend on whether Singaporeans think that what they are doing is really for the benefit of the patients. Given the spite of controversies and checks by the National Council of Social Service (NCSS) to dig out similar cases of that of NKF's, more Singaporeans have become more skeptical of the ulterior motives of charity shows. Recently the Singapore Association of the Visually Handicapped (SAVH) has been found out to have irregularities, ranging from lack of proper segregration of duties and a majority of sighted people than blind members in the register to problematic accounting. In addition, the higher minimal donation amount (of $8) may deter the general Singaporeans from donating.
A true dedication from the organisers that the prizes serve as a secondary motivation for viewers to call may show that the charity really appeals for support from Singaporeans. Prizes are only motivation for Singaporeans to use charity calls as an indirect and alternative form of gambling. Singaporeans should decide for themselves whether they will get "value of their money" by donating to the respective charity organisations. A less complicated organisation will definitely help in allowing more funds to benefit the patients than to give them out to workers as renumerations.
Your view on yourself:
You are down-to-earth and people like you because you are so straightforward. You are an efficient problem solver because you will listen to both sides of an argument before making a decision that usually appeals to both parties.
The type of girlfriend/boyfriend you are looking for:
You are a true romantic. When you are in love, you will do anything and everything to keep your love true.
Your readiness to commit to a relationship:You are ready to commit as soon as you meet the right person. And you believe you will pretty much know as soon as you might that person.
The seriousness of your love:
You are very serious about relationships and aren't interested in wasting time with people you don't really like. If you meet the right person, you will fall deeply and beautifully in love.
Your views on education:
Education is very important in life. You want to study hard and learn as much as you can.
The right job for you:
You're a practical person and will choose a secure job with a steady income. Knowing what you like to do is important. Find a regular job doing just that and you'll be set for life.
How do you view success:
You are confident that you will be successful in your chosen career and nothing will stop you from trying.
What are you most afraid of:
You are afraid of things that you cannot control. Sometimes you show your anger to cover up how you feel.
Who is your true self:You are mature, reasonable, honest and give good advice. People ask for your comments on all sorts of different issues. Sometimes you might find yourself in a dilemma when trapped with a problem, which your heart rather than your head needs to solve.
Thanks to Goh Wei Zhong for introducing to this Personality Test. You may want to try it at this location.